Navigating Decision Overload: Strategies for Simplifying Your Daily Choices
Ever feel like your brain just… can’t anymore? Like deciding what to make for dinner feels as hard as choosing a mortgage? That’s decision overload, and you’re not imagining it.
Every day, women make hundreds of micro-decisions. What to wear, what to feed the kids, how to respond to that passive-aggressive email, whether to say yes to another invite, and when (or if) you’ll squeeze in a workout. It’s no wonder by 3 p.m., you’re exhausted and can’t even choose what show to watch on Netflix.
Let’s talk about why decision fatigue hits so hard and how to make your daily life feel less like a mental obstacle course.
What Is Decision Overload?
Decision overload (also called decision fatigue) is what happens when your brain gets maxed out from making too many choices. Even small ones add up. The more decisions you have to make, the more mentally drained you become—making even simple things feel overwhelming.
And for many women, this goes beyond “What’s for dinner?” You’re managing work demands, emotional labor at home, social calendars, family logistics, and often being the default planner/rememberer/doer of everything.
It’s not that you’re bad at making decisions. You’re human and you’re overloaded.
Signs You’re Dealing With Decision Fatigue
You feel paralyzed when faced with small choices
You procrastinate basic tasks
You’re more irritable or snappier than usual
You start making impulsive decisions just to be done
You find yourself numbing out with screens, snacks, or shopping
Sound familiar? If so, it’s time to simplify.
Strategies to Cut Through the Chaos
Automate the Easy Stuff
Not everything deserves your full mental energy. Try creating default choices for the repetitive stuff:
A weekly meal rotation
A “uniform” or go-to outfit formula
A standing grocery list
Pre-set morning and evening routines
When your brain knows what to expect, it doesn’t have to work so hard. Think of it as reducing mental clutter.
Use the Two-Minute Rule
If something will take two minutes or less, do it right away. Reply to the text. Toss the laundry in. Schedule the dentist appointment. This helps prevent tiny tasks from piling up and overwhelming your brain later.
Decide Once
This is a favorite from productivity expert Emily P. Freeman - decide once. Instead of deciding every week what self-care you’ll do, pick one go-to thing: “Every Sunday morning, I take a walk alone.” Done. You don’t have to keep re-deciding.
Limit Your Daily Decisions
Try giving yourself decision “budgets.” For example, decide that you’ll only check your calendar twice a day. Or limit your outfit options to a few go-to combinations. The fewer choices you face, the less drained you’ll feel.
Ask Yourself: Does This Actually Need My Attention?
Just because a decision is in front of you doesn’t mean it needs to be you making it. Delegate when possible. Let someone else pick the restaurant. Let the group chat decide the weekend plans. It’s okay to opt out of the mental load.
Make Space to Pause
Sometimes we rush into decisions just to avoid sitting with uncertainty. Try building in small pauses (i.e., five minutes of quiet, a quick journal entry, or a walk around the block) before you answer or act. A little space can bring a lot of clarity.
You Don’t Have to Do It All Perfectly
Here’s the truth: simplifying your decisions isn’t about being rigid or robotic. When done effectively and consistently, it allows you to focus on what really matters to you most: your peace, your presence, and your well-being. You are not lazy, unmotivated, or forgetful. You are carrying a lot. By reducing the number of choices you face each day, you’re creating space to breathe.
Start Working With A Burnout Therapist in New York, NY
If burnout is taking a toll on your mind and body, you don’t have to face it alone. Working with a burnout therapist in New York can help you process stress, reconnect with your values, and start feeling like yourself again. Reach out to The Lavender Therapy by following these simple steps:
Schedule a consultation today.
Learn more from my blogs here.
Start taking the first step to improving your mental health!
Other Services I Offer Across New York
Burnout therapy is not the only form of support I offer from my New York-based practice. I provide a variety of specialized services, whether you're seeking help with infertility and pregnancy loss support, postpartum and pregnancy challenges, women’s therapy, or family planning, I’m here to offer guidance and care every step of the way.
About The Author:
Dr. Ruby Rhoden is a New York-based licensed psychologist who is dedicated to uplifting women through life changes and challenges, including reproduction and parent burnout. She understands how unhelpful behavior patterns and mental health disorders uniquely impact women and uses evidence-based techniques to usher in sustainable change and relief. Dr. Ruby is dedicated to helping women develop healthier habits and relationships with themselves and their bodies so they can connect to others and the world around them again. Dr. Ruby studied at Cornell University and Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey for her Bachelor’s and Doctoral degrees, respectively. In her free time, she enjoys watching reality TV, supporting small businesses, and writing blog posts to remind all women that they are not alone.
